Yeah, definitely agree there. It feels like I've only heard one song off that album in like 7-8 years, and that was when I was going taking a nostalgia trip through an old playlist. When I've had Seether cravings I'm always going back to their old stuff.
Sort of a similar feeling with Trivium. I love everything pre-Silence in the Snow, and I think I'm one of three people that actually really like SITS for what it was despite how drastic of a shift it was. But their stuff post-SITS has been, I dunno..... not bad by any means, it just doesn't grab me like their old stuff. Maybe it's nostalgia, maybe my tastes are different, maybe it's their direction. Or all three. Lol
I'll still binge their albums when they come out, but after that I sort of stop listening to them barring my favorite tracks.